Charted
Friday, Nov. 20, 2026The business of health, by the numbers
Live trackersDeal tracker $7.07B raisedFDA clearances 293 510(k)s in OctoberForm D raises $839M in 30 daysNew trials 266 Phase 2/3 in 30 days
Payers & Policy·Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services

CMS proposes narrowing Medicare Advantage Star Ratings to 15 measures and easing plan entry

The proposal would let new plans prove network adequacy after launch, set a nutrition standard for food benefits, and create a mandatory 10-year state model, ADVaNCE MA, starting in 2029.

From a CMS press release published Nov. 20, 2026
"Life in the Community," a sculpture installation outside the Health Care Financing Administration Building in Woodlawn, Md., now the headquarters of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
"Life in the Community," a sculpture installation outside the Health Care Financing Administration Building in Woodlawn, Md., now the headquarters of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. File photo.Carol M. Highsmith / Library of Congress (public domain)

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services on Nov. 20 proposed rewriting parts of Medicare Advantage and Part D. The proposal would focus plan Star Ratings on 15 measures, let new insurers show their provider networks are adequate after they launch rather than when they apply, and set a nutrition standard for food benefits.

The proposed rule comes with a new mandatory, 10-year CMS Innovation Center model called ADVaNCE MA. CMS said the model would launch in 2029 in select states and would test quality incentives and a new approach to risk adjustment.

Why it matters: Star Ratings drive the quality bonus payments that Medicare Advantage insurers earn. CMS said its proposed method changes would make high ratings, and the bonuses tied to them, harder to reach. The network adequacy change would remove a step that CMS called a significant hurdle for insurers trying to enter new markets, so regional and national carriers could face more competition.

Ratings, networks and food benefits

The Star Ratings proposal would put more weight on clinical outcomes and patient experience. It would keep some process measures in high-priority areas where CMS said plan performance is still low. For comparison, CMS currently rates Medicare Advantage drug contracts on as many as 43 measures. In the 2027 Star Ratings released in October, about 37% of those contracts earned four stars or more, according to the agency's fact sheet.

Under current rules, insurers must prove their networks meet adequacy standards during the application process. The proposal would move that test to the plan's first year of operation. CMS said the change would also cut down on application appeals and bid delays.

CMS also proposed merging three behavioral health specialty types into one category for network adequacy purposes: clinical psychology, clinical social work, and outpatient behavioral health. The agency said this would give plans more flexibility in building behavioral health networks. It also said the change would reduce what it called disproportionate negotiating leverage that can push up costs. Separately, CMS proposed expanding the telehealth credit that plans can count toward network requirements.

On food, the proposal would require food and beverage supplemental benefits to consist of whole, nutrient-dense foods consistent with the 2025–2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans. That would include the food and produce benefit offered to chronically ill enrollees, which CMS said was used almost 40 million times in 2025. Items that fall short of the standard, such as some high-calorie oral nutritional supplements, could still be covered if a clinician recommends them for an enrollee's medical needs.

"People with Medicare should be able to choose coverage based on what matters most to them — quality, affordability, and access," CMS Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz said in the release.

The ADVaNCE MA model

CMS said ADVaNCE MA is meant to put regional health plans on more even footing with large national carriers. Participating plans could target certain preventive supplemental benefits to enrollees who receive the low-income subsidy: food and produce, transportation for non-medical needs, and caregiver support.

The model would gradually tie payment to quality performance and encourage plans to compete within each state. It would also run a new CMMI Inferred Risk Adjustment Model in a shadow test, combining several methods. CMS said it is considering carving out dialysis payment for end-stage renal disease within the model at a later date. The release does not say which states would take part or how CMS would choose them.

"This model can help people with Medicare Advantage get more transparent, high-value care," CMS Innovation Center Director Abe Sutton said.

The rule also includes proposals to bring more plan options and competition to markets served by dual eligible special needs plans, which combine Medicare and Medicaid benefits. These proposals would allow more flexible arrangements between those plans and Medicaid managed care plans. The release does not spell out the specific changes.

What comes next

Comments on the proposed rule will be accepted for 60 days after it is published in the Federal Register. The fact sheet's title places the policies in contract year 2028. CMS also issued a request for information on expanding primary care networks and on using artificial intelligence, which the agency also called "Super Intelligence," to inform future policy.

The release does not include cost or savings estimates for the proposals, and it does not give the full list of the 15 measures. Those details, the states chosen for ADVaNCE MA, and the final version of the rule are the next things to watch.

Sara Montes de Oca is the Editor in Chief of Charted. She previously worked as a correspondent and producer in Washington, D.C., covering business, finance, and politics. Drafted with automated tools from the sources listed with this story and checked against them before publishing. How we report.

More Payers & Policy

More
Newsletter

Charted Daily

The day's deals, FDA decisions and policy moves, by the numbers. Free. Sign up now to get the first edition.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.