Charted
Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2026The business of health, by the numbers
Live trackersDeal tracker $7.07B raisedFDA clearances 293 510(k)s in OctoberForm D raises $839M in 30 daysNew trials 266 Phase 2/3 in 30 days
Payers & Policy·Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services

CMS fraud rule would extrapolate Medicare Advantage audits and police brokers, aiming for nearly $90 billion

The proposed CRUSH rule would codify Medicare Advantage audit extrapolation back to 2018, make plans report suspected fraud, require MA clinicians to enroll in Original Medicare and tighten rules for Marketplace brokers.

From a CMS press release and fact sheets published Nov. 16, 2026, and the proposed rule posted for public inspection at the Federal Register the same day
Robert F. Kennedy Jr., secretary of health and human services, in his 2025 official portrait.
Robert F. Kennedy Jr., secretary of health and human services, in his 2025 official portrait. File photo.U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (public domain)

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services proposed a sweeping anti-fraud rule on Nov. 16 that reaches Medicare Advantage insurers, Medicaid programs, medical equipment suppliers and the brokers who sell Affordable Care Act coverage. CMS estimates the package would save the federal budget nearly $90 billion from 2027 through 2036, against about $378.51 million in costs.

The agency calls it the Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare, or CRUSH, proposed rule (CMS-6098-P). CMS said it is a standalone rule, separate from the annual payment rules, and that it intends to write program integrity rules like it every year.

Why it matters: The one provision CMS's fact sheet attaches a dollar figure to lands on Medicare Advantage plans. CMS proposes to codify how it audits plans' diagnosis coding, including extrapolating audit findings starting with payment year 2018, an approach it estimates would recover about $9 billion in overpayments per payment year on average. Other provisions would change how clinicians join MA networks and how brokers keep access to the Marketplace.

What plans and providers would face

Under the Risk Adjustment Data Validation program, CMS checks whether medical records support the diagnoses plans submit for risk-adjusted payment. The proposal would codify that CMS will not apply a fee-for-service adjuster, that it will set the sampling method, and that extrapolation begins with 2018 audits, according to the fact sheet.

MA organizations and Part D sponsors would have to report substantiated or suspected fraud, waste and abuse to CMS rather than doing so voluntarily. CMS said only 46% of Part C and D contracts reported such referrals for 2025, and only 19% reported any payment suspensions based on credible allegations of fraud.

Clinicians and suppliers billing MA plans would have to be enrolled in Original Medicare, with Program of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly plans excepted. That would subject them to Medicare's screening, including site visits and fingerprint-based background checks. If finalized, the requirement would start with the plan year beginning two years after the final rule is published.

All providers would have 30 days to report any change to their Medicare enrollment, instead of up to 90 days for some changes today. CMS could also deny or revoke enrollment when it cannot confirm the identity of an owner or manager. Medical equipment suppliers would face a ban on unsolicited texts, social media messages, door-to-door visits and emails without an opt-out, subject to the exceptions that apply to phone calls, and would have to disclose more affiliated companies, such as marketing and fulfillment firms.

"For too long, the system has paid first and asked questions later, leaving us to chase stolen dollars after they're gone," Kim Brandt, CMS deputy administrator and chief operating officer, said in the release.

Medicaid and the Marketplace

States could rely on a credible-allegation-of-fraud finding made by CMS or another federal agency to suspend payments to a provider. They would have to collect National Provider Identifiers for all eligible providers and use electronic visit verification data in prepayment review of personal care and home health claims. Medicaid fee-for-service providers would have 60 days to report and return overpayments they identify, matching rules elsewhere in Medicare and Medicaid.

For the Marketplace, CMS would restrict access for agents, brokers and web-brokers with certain felony convictions, let it suspend their agreements on a credible allegation of abusive conduct, and prohibit access to Marketplace systems from outside the U.S., including through virtual private networks.

"CRUSH would give CMS stronger tools to block fraudulent payments, remove dishonest providers, and protect Americans from schemes that exploit their healthcare coverage," Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said.

The backdrop

The rule arrived the same day CMS published fiscal 2026 improper payment estimates of $33.96 billion, or 7.32%, in Original Medicare, $23.86 billion in Medicare Part C and $46.84 billion in Medicaid. CMS notes that improper payment rates do not measure fraud. The agency drew more than 560 comments on a February request for information that informed the proposal, and it recently finalized a separate home health rule that lets it date Medicare revocations back to when noncompliance began.

Comments on CRUSH are due Jan. 19, 2027, CMS said. The proposal is scheduled to appear in the Federal Register on Nov. 19.

Sara Montes de Oca is the Editor in Chief of Charted. She previously worked as a correspondent and producer in Washington, D.C., covering business, finance, and politics. Drafted with automated tools from the sources listed with this story and checked against them before publishing. How we report.

More Payers & Policy

More
Newsletter

Charted Daily

The day's deals, FDA decisions and policy moves, by the numbers. Free. Sign up now to get the first edition.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.